CO129-194 - Governor Hennessy Administrator Tonnochy - 1881 [8-9] — Page 107

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

106

"Contracts of Service within the meaning of Ordinance

There cannot in my opinion be a Contract of Service according to Law unless there be also a Contract of hiring, otherwise it would be a unilateral "Contract which could not be enforced. The following passage taken from Addison on Contracts p. 682 I think correctly states the law. "In order to constitute a Contract of hiring and Service there must either be express or implied mutual engagement binding one party to employ and remunerate and the other to serve for a determinate period.

I think there can be no doubt that the parties alluded to are considered free and not under any Contract of Service whatever and that the course taken by the Emigration Officer in so regarding them is strictly in accordance with the question giving rise to it.

Again, in December 1878 a query was made as to whether the giving of a promissory note to repay by instalments out of earnings in British Guiana for certain advances such as Passage money, Clothing, Cash, etc., made here constituted a Contract of Service. This was referred to Mr. Phillippo, and on the 4th of that month he wrote: "I do not consider that the fact of an Immigrant giving a promissory note to be paid by instalments out of earnings in British Guiana amounts to a Contract of Service and that technically under the Ordinance such an Immigrant must be considered free."

Edit History

2026-05-22 13:15:16 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
106"Contracts of Service within the meaning of OrdinanceThere cannot in my opinion be a Contract of Service according to Law unless there be also a Contract of hiring, otherwise it would be a unilateral "Contract which could not be enforced. The following passage taken from Addison on Contracts p. 682 I think correctly states the law. "In order to constitute a Contract of hiring and Service there must either be express or implied mutual engagement binding one party to employ and remunerate and the other to serve for a determinate period.I think there can be no doubt that the parties alluded to are considered free and not under any Contract of Service whatever and that the course taken by the Emigration Officer in so regarding them is strictly in accordance with the question giving rise to it.Again, in December 1878 a query was made as to whether the giving of a promissory note to repay by instalments out of earnings in British Guiana for certain advances such as Passage money, Clothing, Cash, etc., made here constituted a Contract of Service. This was referred to Mr. Phillippo, and on the 4th of that month he wrote: "I do not consider that the fact of an Immigrant giving a promissory note to be paid by instalments out of earnings in British Guiana amounts to a Contract of Service and that technically under the Ordinance such an Immigrant must be considered free."
Baseline (Original)
106" Contracts of Service within theI meaning of OrdinanThere cannot in my opinion be a Contract of.Law Service according of unless there be also: a Contract of hiring, otherwise "it w would be - unilateral "Contract which could not be"" enforced. The following passage" taken from Addison on Contracts" p. 682 I think correctly states "the law. "In order to constitute a Contract of hiring and Vervice there must either be expresse.mutual engengager implied binding" one party to employ ermuncrate and the other to "terrr"foretoZfor.سے determinate period.I think there that the parties alluded meet thesidered.OL free anto undemigrantscrno Contract of" of Service whatever and that" the course taken by "Emigration Officer in so ::regarding them is strictly" in accordance the qAgain.uestion giving with.lars. in December 1878 as to whether the promissory note to repay by instalmente out of in British Guiana earnings certain advanceò such as Passage money, Clothing, Cash, xo :AZCoreferredth made here Contract of Service was. to Mr Phillippo, and on the 4 of that mouth he wrote: I do not" consider that the fact of "Immigrant giving a promicsory note to be paid by instalments "out of earnings in British Guiana" amounts to a Contract of Service and that technically under. the Ordinance such an Immigrant must -1
2026-05-22 13:15:16 · Baseline
View content

106

" Contracts of Service within the

I meaning of

Ordinan

There cannot in my opinion

be a Contract of.

Law

Service according

of

unless there be also

: a Contract of hiring, otherwise

"it w

would be

-

unilateral

"Contract which could not be

"

" enforced. The following passage " taken from Addison on Contracts " p. 682 I think correctly states "the law. "In order to constitute

a Contract of hiring

and

Vervice there must either be

expresse.

mutual eng

engager

implied

binding

" one party to employ

ermuncrate and the other to

"terrr

"fore

to

Z

for.

سے

determinate

period. I think there

that the parties alluded

meet the

sidered.

OL

free

anto und

emigrants

crno Contract

of

" of Service whatever and that " the course taken by "Emigration Officer in so

::regarding them is strictly

" in accordance

the q

Again.

uestion

giving

with.

lars.

in December 1878

as to whether the

promissory note to

repay by instalmente out of

in British Guiana earnings

certain advanceò such as

Passage money, Clothing, Cash, xo :

AZ

Co

referred

th

made here

Contract of Service was. to Mr Phillippo, and on the 4 of that mouth he wrote: I do not

" consider that the fact of "Immigrant giving a promicsory note to be paid by instalments "out of earnings in British Guiana " amounts to a Contract of Service and that technically under. the Ordinance such an Immigrant

must

-1

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.